Carlyle Pastoral Charge was formed as a new United Church charge in 1925, part of Arcola Presbytery and consisting of congregations at Carlyle, Moose Creek, and Sutherland. Moose Creek had been a local union church since around 1921, combining Methodist and Presbyterian congregations in the area. As part of the United Church, Moose Creek continued as a preaching appointment until June 30, 1992, when it closed.