Theodore Pastoral Charge was formed as a new United Church charge around 1926, as part of Yorkton Presbytery. Initially, the charge included preaching points at Theodore, Creekside and Beaverdale. By 1951, the charge contained preaching points at Creekside, Jedburgh, Theodore, Sheho and Springside, and had been re-named Theodore-Sheho Pastoral Charge. The name reverted back to Theodore Pastoral Charge by 1958. Willowbrook was added to preaching points, until it closed ca.1982.

Sometime before 1994, the charge was re-named Theodore-Springside Pastoral Charge, reflecting the remaining preaching points at St. Paul's United Church (Theodore) and Springside. On December 15, 2018, the Springside point was officially closed and the charge returned to the name Theodore Pastoral Charge.