Carlyle Pastoral Charge was formed as a new United Church charge in 1925, part of Arcola Presbytery and consisting of congregations at Carlyle, Moose Creek, and Sutherland. Moose Creek had been a local union church since around 1921, combining Methodist and Presbyterian congregations in the area. As part of the United Church, Moose Creek continued as a preaching appointment until June 30, 1992, when it closed.

Sutherland Pastoral Charge was formed 1925, as part of Saskatoon Presbytery and containing preaching points at St. Paul's United Church, in Sutherland, and Floral. Prior to union, St. Paul's had been a Presbyterian Church (built ca.1910), whose congregations had joined with local Methodists in the 1920s, after their church closed. After a fire, in 1943, the congregation worshipped for 3 years at Sutherland School (across the street), until the church was rebuilt. By 1951, the charge included Second Street United (Saskatoon) and Cory. Second Street returned to a separate charge ca.1955. In 1956, Sutherland became part of Saskatoon and around the same time the charge was renamed Saskatoon St. Paul's Pastoral Charge.